Advertiser disclosure: some links on this page may be affiliate links, meaning BrokerCatalogue may earn a commission if you buy an evaluation. This never affects the data shown here, which is drawn from our catalogue and compared mechanically. How we make money.
Data refreshed 24 Sep 2026 · Compiled by David Ispiryan · Lucid Trading facts verified by BrokerCatalogue research desk (from the firm's own site) on 2026-09-24 · Topstep facts verified by BrokerCatalogue research desk (from the firm's own site) on 2026-09-24
AI visibility score 3.3 / 100 · AI visibility rank #24 · Founded 2024
Lucid Trading is a proprietary trading firm based in Dover, United States, founded in 2024. It offers one-step, instant-funding evaluations on futures. Funded accounts go up to $150,000 (up to 5 funded…
Open the Lucid Trading profileAI visibility score 31.4 / 100 · AI visibility rank #4 · Founded 2012
Topstep is a proprietary trading firm based in Chicago, United States, founded in 2012. It offers one-step evaluations on futures. Funded accounts go up to $150,000. The profit split is 90% (100%…
Open the Topstep profileLucid Trading (Dover, United States, founded 2024) scores 3.3 / 100 on the Q3 2026 AI Visibility Index (rank #24 of 76 prop firms), named in 5% of AI answers, runs Instant funding, One-step evaluations, funds accounts up to $150,000 (up to 5 funded accounts) and offers MotiveWave, NinjaTrader, Quantower, Rithmic, Tradesea, Tradovate. Topstep (Chicago, United States, founded 2012) scores 31.4 / 100 on the Q3 2026 AI Visibility Index (rank #4 of 76 prop firms), named in 39% of AI answers, runs One-step evaluations, funds accounts up to $150,000, pays a 90% (100% of first $10,000) profit split and offers NinjaTrader, TopstepX, TradingView.
Scored on 8 measurable dimensions where both prop firms have verified data. Dimensions missing for either side are excluded rather than guessed. This is a data summary, not a recommendation.
| Criteria | Lucid Trading | Topstep |
|---|---|---|
| AI visibility score | 3.3 / 100 | 31.4 / 100 |
| AI visibility rank | #24 | #4 |
| Named in AI answers | 5% | 39% |
| AI sentiment (0–100) | 4 | 39 |
| Founded | 2024 | 2012 |
| Headquarters | Dover, United States | Chicago, United States |
| Evaluation models | Instant funding, One-step | One-step |
| Asset classes | Futures | Futures |
| Platforms | MotiveWave, NinjaTrader, Quantower, Rithmic, Tradesea, Tradovate | NinjaTrader, TopstepX, TradingView |
| Maximum allocation | $150,000 (up to 5 funded accounts) | $150,000 |
| Profit split | Not verified | 90% (100% of first $10,000) |
| Challenge fee from | Not verified | $49/month ($50K Combine) |
| Account sizes | $25k, $50k, $100k, $150k | $50k, $100k, $150k |
| Payout frequency | same-day (about 15 minutes from request to bank per site) | on demand (instant payouts after 5 winning days or 3-day consistency path) |
| Daily drawdown limit | Not verified | none (optional Daily Loss Limit $1,000 on $50K) |
| Maximum drawdown | Not verified | trailing $2,000 on $50K (4%, end-of-day) |
| Minimum trading days | Not verified | 2 |
| Time limit | none | none |
| News trading | Not verified | Yes |
| Weekend holding | No | No |
| EAs / algos allowed | Not verified | Restricted |
| Broker backing | Not verified | Topstep Brokerage LLC (NFA-registered introducing broker, affiliate) |
| Status | active | active |
Highlighted cells mark the stronger value where a direction is objectively better (e.g. more licences, lower fees). "Not verified" means the field is not yet in our catalogue for that prop firm — we never fill gaps with estimates.
| Engine | Lucid Trading | Topstep |
|---|---|---|
| ChatGPT | 2.1 | 56 |
| Perplexity | 2.5 | 38.6 |
| Gemini | 1.9 | 33.9 |
| Claude | 8.4 | 17.9 |
| Google AI Mode | 3.2 | 41.6 |
| Google AI Overview | 21.8 | 30.7 |
| Google top-10 | 0 | 0.2 |
Scores 0–100 from the Pipswire AI Visibility Index, Q3 2026. Higher means the engine names the firm more often and more favourably.
Topstep scores higher on the Q3 2026 Pipswire AI Visibility Index (3.3 / 100 vs 31.4 / 100), which measures how often ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Claude and Google name a firm when traders ask which prop firm to use.
Lucid Trading: MotiveWave, NinjaTrader, Quantower, Rithmic, Tradesea, Tradovate. Topstep: NinjaTrader, TopstepX, TradingView.
Risk warning: prop firms are not regulated brokers or investment firms. Evaluations are paid, fees are usually non-refundable, most accounts are simulated, and a firm can change its rules or stop paying out. Most participants fail the evaluation. Nothing on this page is financial advice; read the firm's terms before you pay. Full risk disclosure.